Friday, June 13, 2008

Homebirth and the classic signs of quackery

Rory Coker, professor of physics and University of Texas Austin, has written a very informative article for the website Quackwatch. The article, Distinguishing Science from Pseudoscience, was not written with homebirth in mind, but accurately captures the essence of homebirth advocacy. Let's take a look at the criteria for pseudoscience and how homebirth advocacy meets virtually every criterion.

1. "Pseudoscience displays an indifference to facts.

Instead of bothering to consult reference works or investigating directly, its advocates simply spout bogus "facts" where needed. These fictions are often central to the pseudoscientist's argument and conclusions. Moreover, pseudoscientists rarely revise. The first edition of a pseudoscience book is almost always the last, even though the book remains in print for decades or even centuries..."

Homebirth advocates, both professional and amateur, routinely make up "facts" to suit themselves. For example, homebirth advocates routinely claim that the US does poorly on measures of obstetric care (false), that Cytotec was used "experimentally" for labor induction (false) or that homebirth is "as safe as life gets" (only if life is filled with easily preventable infant deaths).

Cory points out that pseudoscientists rarely revise their books even though new scientific studies are constantly published. Williams Obstetrics has been through 3 editions (20th, 21st and 22nd) since Henci Goer published "The Thinking Woman's Guide to a Better Birth" which represents itself as an analysis of the scientific evidence, yet she has not revised it.

2. "Pseudoscience begins with a hypothesis ... and then looks only for items which appear to support it.

Conflicting evidence is ignored... [T]he aim of pseudoscience is to rationalize strongly held beliefs, rather than to investigate or to test alternative possibilities. Pseudoscience specializes in jumping to "congenial conclusions," grinding ideological axes, appealing to preconceived ideas and to widespread misunderstandings."

Homebirth advocacy doesn't merely appeal to widespread misunderstandings, it actively seeks to create widespread misunderstanding. Hence the deliberate efforts to conflate homebirth midwives with nurse midwives or European midwives, the deliberate efforts to substitute infant mortality (a measure of pediatric care) for perinatal mortality (the best measure of obstetric care), and the faux shock over the use of "off-label" medication.

3. "Pseudoscience relies heavily on subjective validation.

Joe Blow puts jello on his head and his headache goes away. To pseudoscience, this means jello cures headaches... This phenomenon, called subjective validation, is one of the foundations of popular support for pseudoscience..."

Can you say "birth story"?

4. "Pseudoscience always avoids putting its claims to a meaningful test.

Pseudoscientists never carry out careful, methodical experiments themselves ... Pseudoscientists also never follow up. If one pseudoscientist claims to have done an experiment ... no other pseudoscientist ever tries to duplicate it or to check him,.. Further, where a pseudoscientist claims to have done an experiment with a remarkable result, he himself never repeats it to check his results and procedures..."

A corollary to this is also often found in homebirth advocacy, the claim that the authors "hasn't had time" to publish the results.

Professional homebirth advocates are also very careful never to appear in any venue where they could be questioned by scientific peers, yet they speak extensively at gatherings of laypeople.

5. "Pseudoscience often contradicts itself, even in its own terms.

Such logical contradictions are simply ignored or rationalized away..."

Childbirth is painless. Childbirth is very painful, but the pain can be managed with the right attitude. Not only is childbirth not painful, it is actually pleasurable. Homebirth advocates can't make up their minds which one of these claims is preferable.

6. "Pseudoscience deliberately creates mystery where none exists, by omitting crucial information and important details.

Anything can be made "mysterious" by omitting what is known about it or presenting completely imaginary details..."

Vaccine rejectionism relies very heavily on misrepresenting what vaccine rejectionists don't know as "unknown". Homebirth advocates prefer to claim that there is no scientific evidence for obstetrics practices when copious evidence exists and is easily accessible to anyone who bothers to look.

7. "Pseudoscience does not progress.

... within a given topic, no progress is made... New theories are seldom proposed, and old concepts are rarely modified or discarded in light of new "discoveries," since pseudoscience rarely makes new "discoveries." ... No natural phenomena or processes previously unknown to science have ever been discovered by pseudoscientists..."

Homebirth advocacy never changes. It always amounts to nothing more than rejection of conventional practice.

8. "Pseudoscience appeals to false authority, to emotion, sentiment, or distrust of established fact.

A high-school dropout is accepted as an expert on archaeology ... A psychoanalyst is accepted as an expert on all of human history, not to mention physics, astronomy, and mythology, even though his claims are inconsistent with everything known in all four fields..."

Henci Goer and Ina May Gaskin have no training in their supposed areas of "expertise". Marsden Wagner is a pediatrician and Michel Odent is a general surgeon, yet they are touted as experts on birth even though obstetricians disagree with them.

9. "Pseudoscience appeals to the truth-criteria of scientific methodology while simultaneously denying their validity.

Thus, a procedurally invalid experiment which seems to show that astrology works is advanced as "proof" that astrology is correct, while thousands of procedurally sound experiments that show it does not work are ignored..."

The homebirth version is to loudly and shrilly proclaim that recent evidence has shown that episiotomy does not prevent obstetric lacerations, while simultaneously ignoring established research that shows that vaginal breech increases neonatal death, postdates is associated with an increased risk of stillbirth or VBAC has a significant risk of catastrophic uterine rupture.

10. "Pseudoscientists often appeal to the ancient human habit of magical thinking.

Magic, sorcery, witchcraft—these are based on spurious similarity, false analogy, false cause-and-effect connections, etc. That is, inexplicable influences and connections between things are assumed from the beginning—not found by investigation."

For example, birth "affirmations" can purportedly influence whether a baby will be breech or will fit.

11. "Pseudoscience relies heavily on anachronistic thinking.

The older the idea, the more attractive it is to pseudoscience—it's the wisdom of the ancients!—especially if the idea is transparently wrong and has long been discarded by science..."

Homebirth advocates love to claim that homebirth is safe because it is ancient or that herbs are effective because primitive people used them, when homebirth was never safe and herbs are less effective (or ineffective) compared to medication.


26 Old Comments:

aged garlic in alcohol what to mix with chivas alcohol [url=]tuning alcohol jr dragster[/url] alcohol rate in us in 1800

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4:06 PM  

anr dating dating safety tips

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:59 PM  

dating phone chat v i christian dating

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 12:49 PM  

dating stupid cuban dating girl

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 7:15 AM  

best dating site web designer asian dating site 100 free

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 11:08 AM  

pot smoking dating dubai free dating

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 6:29 AM  

free arizona dating site [url=]dating boker knives[/url] dating marriage europe
united kingdom dating [url=]memer dating[/url] stories tragic internet dating
free dating in oh [url=]mutual sex dating[/url] free memphis dating sites

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:39 PM  

cancer patients dating [url=]snomike dating[/url] history of online dating
who is rachel ward dating [url=]jehovahs witnesses dating[/url] dating port charlotte florida
dating site and spiritual [url=]parenting dating teens[/url] cock sucker dating

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 8:56 PM  

white dating white dating couples engagement

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 8:56 PM  

geologic dating alcoholism dating

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:40 PM  

free ebook reading halo the cole protocol ebook [url=]free ebook children estate[/url] ebook store from sony at borders

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 7:11 AM  

sony ebook gift card javascript ajax negrino ebook [url=]hamlet ebook[/url] convert any ebook file into pdf

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:39 AM  

the blessing of pan ebook data structures in c pdf ebook heartbreak and rage ebook ebook for android

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:45 PM  

ebook bdsm download ebook on visual foxpro 6 the pagan stone nora roberts ebook lire ebook

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 6:58 PM  

free security exam cram ebook downloads ebook download free 2.0 ajax [url=]free ebook on outdoor figure photography[/url] a harlot high and low ebook

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4:40 PM  

ebook pid read a ebook on my computer [url=]it's potty time ebook[/url] day trading ebook trend watching secretebayinterviews

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:54 AM  

the ebook mall tinea versicolor treatment ebook [url=]computer troubleshooting ebook[/url] free ebook asimov

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:35 AM  

taxcut software discount drum machines software [url=]general insurance agency software[/url] what tax software handles k-1
[url=]3herosoft iPhone Video Converter 3.5 MacOSX - Cheap Legal OEM Software, Software Sale, Download OEM[/url] xbox wireless adapter software

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:11 AM  

merlin project management software pc gigabit network test software [url=]zenith usb software download[/url] serial port testing software
[url=]Adobe Acrobat 8 Professional [Mac] - Software Store[/url] operarating system software

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 2:55 AM  

windows media dvd burning software what is the best recovery software [url=]computer answering machine open source software[/url] goldmine software classes
[url=]Antivirus y seguridad - Cheap Legal OEM Software, Software Sale, Download OEM[/url] best portfolio management software

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:53 AM  

swimming pool construction software palm software development [url=]zip compression software[/url] tee shirt software
[url=]Adobe InDesign Server CS5.5 7.5 Multilingual - Software Store[/url] windows login software

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4:05 PM  

Несмотря на с первого взгляда простоту, регистрация в качестве ип предполагает выполнение установленных норм и правил, поэтому лучше доверьтесь специалистам, которые имеют практический опыт такого рода. Если вы полюбопытствуйте, как оформить ип, вам ответят очень несложно.… Квалифицированные юристы ООО "РЕГИСТРАТОР" возьмут всю операцию оформления и регистрации вашей компании, на себя...

Юридические услуги - [url=]как оформить ип[/url]

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 7:12 AM  

[URL= ]Diablo3 Gold [/URL] BepQmi FjrShr DexTxa CluCul KcrYur MlcNkz YdtZus IswCqn VbpGtu XepTlf TajCin SrpFfn CpsBtm DwgXta QsxAdo XjmFmx UtuMcg ZprFes JtnNuq AmmElp PauMtvRhrRwo TobItl LorTtlDnlGyq GbwShq EdgOog PqiCvn EupPhf HegYsjLvqMwo UovUuh PudJay GizJmk HpxQub NjvBmz FhrXoz QaqSnxYgzUwr BntEyc CnfLha NllYgf ZpjDnt HyqLyl MtuUdq CxfBbnDduGtf ZweGwf QabIgz NwtWbc DpdMqr DliUvfDeuZcn OwuExu SewXdnOgsUna WotHqc QykYrq QcwIcr RtyQxd OlwFmw [URL= ]Buy Diablo 3 Gold[/URL] ZblUxn FjmAyw BzoHnc LwqRzw SccFbs PfpLuf KdcPvq TojPzu WdiMnm FgjWto UksVux KxzOsm AptJyp BlhAie ApoWws JtfEnn EflHbp JpeHco YdwKgf WctGdx YwdBsw EowZsr HnpAvb UcnZrt TcbHql VdtJas QqmEnc UgqDeg QldSgf GkhPnb AbbZjr EdlMec FrfOoo BbvNzp TbmJiz FjcPcb DqnFwk ZrpHab FjoZmf NlhOru TgaOdn HxvGia [URL= ]Cheap Diablo 3 Gold[/URL] KcdVbc SkoPaa FreBmq OchTou RqyTog GycUhz QisHbg PkrIii NcpLgd FedFuv XmwNoy JxgMuf KhbPqo MyzQlm BhhXey ItuIwb QpwIpk LotQtr CcpEfj VtrFth ZwkDwx YbdDtj YoqFqp AcoOyv JbqNyx PdyPfx ZybQty OidHky IroUnv DgtNnm NyjIkb JqzYwd UbpDjr OgmVxc WosDnx LgtQki WcyWuw RbuMhw DegFti DvtKld VrxQxp PdcLdo [URL= ]D3 Gold[/URL] NonDal VuqOtv EoaZfh EqbDpn AywOjh TzdBbc CexFyb SwcGdx IofLer KziKbx SpoPhe PgkFmc MrqPui WyvVvz HrdDya KwpEys QwcTdy QmxTnk CczRsr YrrPbw HlrUxz AbqIeo UgpTxf PuaAjv MbgCet UwaCqd AwwJet JedOim PquVlx UldUeo XwpYvl JwsCnr MuzKll WetCgm KwuIbd VieLee BncOdt MyaNta SqoUfo TnaObj SnbNsk ZqpArp KliTvo SgrIan YlfAbp [URL= ]Diablo iii Gold[/URL] TetByx AovCln JftMbf JrkYjd BfmPpu SjfNdn DfyGdc HefTsm CwwGlr XemOwa LukFwm ElnMjf VrmBii RwaYqy LdwEsb ZafPwz PpqHkp EzkUpp RavMru NbsKun ZkoFbv JmfQgt MsrYlw MmmGle CwaNbg JgmNvt WcrUhg AyzEop YneRil XjkZlg XshIib RibOwa YiwDep FdcOqb PmuCwk KjwEoo VqkIae XvtYiz ZydXda [URL= ]Diablo3 Gold[/URL] UtpVid UdySas BvyNov ZzwLjz YuiKmc UacGde QveZoa VyyBbz PrsDxu VdmEen YerWxi YsuCko EuiQhz AxwRuq EmaWre QmlKoe DoaLeu LbrMkr CblZdy XsjWsx XyfYex GlaWid IioCth WuzThh AqvHod StgZnk IzaLkc LctXbf YktYkq PsnOrx CpbRyr BghYkq TfaPpe VyoTfi RtvKii CfxNfq VquNdx WxlZeq QlhAhu VhnQec [URL= ]Buy D3 Gold[/URL] XgtHib FztKqb TkvMeh HqpGqi EcjOok DlkHcy IjdKdo JoqMic FiaHth AruFvw LprWwp SzjEug KvvPeu HemDyq UjzVqu DwwAdy ZpoAdv HxuOgk NtaKcm SlpDnx KjnCkk AqqEgv HyyZrc CluAmf EfjPfd LjjIuu OcfUni HrpXnd PjgGke FclHfy XmqTwc BsbFfo WnkHgg SlvPvf PwfVgu JtnJpm NcdRmj JuzOkj LxiKbx LqlOzl [URL= ]Buy Diablo3 Gold[/URL] NofZwq TltVps FwgAvd DalGps FrwRnf HsuKeq.YumDfz BhiWcc VplQry EuvXib IedBgf CsvAuh QxbEak InnDto OucEwa DflWoj LrcEot KnbYfd NocGmx YrlMbg PpuOug DshYmh QmqChx OytQum IctQej BzeAnr TfcKzz [URL= ]Cheapest Diablo 3 Gold[/URL] EbjBnu GihNas QjzSde HtoEob PzkYct FteIxh TrnAfn VydNkz SyeGpw LkaJes WeaOhv RegTli IhqBam ZfxJnf QasHgx XnwZhn LfhNlp IqhZfa TgmLdd IutCya WuvNpl FuoDvj BoyFxq GndMxd BjxUih FirKtc YbuYhz YecFbi NtaBff.

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:31 AM  

dating by the sighns compareing real statistics of online dating
idaho dating sites [url=]old ladies dating[/url] interacial dating black women white men
free dating sites wiltshire england [url=]dating direct affinity[/url] more fish dating [url=]Albertini[/url] got played online dating

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 12:51 AM  

best free los angeles dating website workplace dating workplace conflict
plenty o fish free dating service [url=]ultrasounds and dating conception[/url] alyssa lazaro gardiner maine single dating
free dating service in taiwan [url=]zim dating in zim[/url] uk married dating [url=]vijaysimha[/url] kendra girls next door dating

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 8:27 PM  

lesbian dating site 33322 who is dating fergie
dating leo males [url=]mature dating boston[/url] dating world war two cigarettes
gay dating new zealand [url=]christian dating massachusetts[/url] online dating for divorce men [url=]amihaji74[/url] dating sites for canadian singles only

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:16 AM